Pagina 1 di 1

Order of the Red Banner of Labor of the Ukraine

Inviato: sab mar 22, 2014 1:53 am
da Nota_Bene
Established in 1921, about 400 pieces were awarded untill 1933.

This is the one published in Kutsenko's book.

Alexei

Re: Order of the Red Banner of Labor of the Ukraine

Inviato: sab mar 22, 2014 1:56 am
da Nota_Bene
A variation with a different anvil.

Alexei

Re: Order of the Red Banner of Labor of the Ukraine

Inviato: sab mar 22, 2014 1:57 am
da Nota_Bene
... and an award document.

Alexei

Re: Order of the Red Banner of Labor of the Ukraine

Inviato: sab mar 22, 2014 3:49 am
da SergioV
Very nice Order, only 400 pieces, and document too is incredible, wow..
in the picture here i see that the anvil is different..
nysale22-pp87_93-2.jpg

Re: Order of the Red Banner of Labor of the Ukraine

Inviato: sab mar 22, 2014 5:42 am
da Nota_Bene
Some experts have argued that No 72 was a fake, but I don't think so. I have examined several pieces with different anvils, and I believe that they are all production variations.

Alexei

Re: Order of the Red Banner of Labor of the Ukraine

Inviato: sab mar 22, 2014 12:23 pm
da ruiz
Very nice, Alexei.

Re: Order of the Red Banner of Labor of the Ukraine

Inviato: sab mar 22, 2014 12:26 pm
da filo
Nota_Bene ha scritto:Some experts have argued that No 72 was a fake, but I don't think so. I have examined several pieces with different anvils, and I believe that they are all production variations.

Alexei
I could only find high numbers: 260-261-330-877-886.
25.jpg
_1_~2.JPG
post-767-1309559761.jpg

Re: Order of the Red Banner of Labor of the Ukraine

Inviato: sab mar 22, 2014 7:37 pm
da GC*
Gentlemen, one never ceases to be amazed when you're around! [264 Never seen this order and I honestly find it supremely beautiful. The large and long red banner, with that superbe enamel is just incredible.

-

Signori, riuscite sempre a farmi rimanere di sasso! [264 Non avevo mai visto prima questo ordine e onestamente lo trovo incredibilmente bello. La bandiera rossa, largha e lunga, con quello smalto superbo è davvero incredibile.

Re: Order of the Red Banner of Labor of the Ukraine

Inviato: dom mar 23, 2014 1:12 am
da Nota_Bene
filo ha scritto: I could only find high numbers: 260-261-330-877-886.
Yet No 262 has a standard anvil. Go figure!

I have seen several more, but I am not at liberty to post them :(

Thanks for posting the scans!

Alexei

Re: Order of the Red Banner of Labor of the Ukraine

Inviato: dom mar 23, 2014 10:22 pm
da Regaleco
The only specimen that i have examined in my hand. Serial n°203 with damaged enamel on the flag.
DSCN2046.JPG
DSCN2047.JPG
DSCN2045.JPG

Re: Order of the Red Banner of Labor of the Ukraine

Inviato: dom mar 23, 2014 11:50 pm
da Nota_Bene
Thanks for posting it! Most collectors never get a chance to see one.

By the way, this is my old buddy - I have examined it about ten years ago.

Alexei

Re: Order of the Red Banner of Labor of the Ukraine

Inviato: mar apr 08, 2014 11:28 pm
da SergioV
Prototype Order of the Red Banner of Labor of Ukraine.
Type 2. Unnumbered, 1925, Gold, silver and brass.
$ 250,000 [argh [argh [argh
was.jpg

Re: Order of the Red Banner of Labor of the Ukraine

Inviato: mer apr 09, 2014 3:51 am
da Nota_Bene
Thanks for posting it, it's an amazing piece! [264

Alexei

Re: Order of the Red Banner of Labor of the Ukraine

Inviato: sab apr 19, 2014 9:41 pm
da Lapa
SergioV ha scritto:
Prototype Order of the Red Banner of Labor of Ukraine.
Type 2. Unnumbered, 1925, Gold, silver and brass.
$ 250,000 [argh [argh [argh
Sergio,

This piece has largely been discussed and commented on Russian forums, and although there is no consensus, the majority of knowledgeable people tend to think that it is a fantasy that was made some time ago on the basis of the sketches for the proposed order.

Marc

Re: Order of the Red Banner of Labor of the Ukraine

Inviato: sab apr 19, 2014 9:59 pm
da SergioV
Lapa ha scritto:
SergioV ha scritto:
Prototype Order of the Red Banner of Labor of Ukraine.
Type 2. Unnumbered, 1925, Gold, silver and brass.
$ 250,000 [argh [argh [argh
Sergio,

This piece has largely been discussed and commented on Russian forums, and although there is no consensus, the majority of knowledgeable people tend to think that it is a fantasy that was made some time ago on the basis of the sketches for the proposed order.

Marc
thank you very much Marc you let me save 250.000 [257
the baltic factory continue to produce fake [notok

Re: Order of the Red Banner of Labor of the Ukraine

Inviato: sab apr 19, 2014 10:17 pm
da Lapa
SergioV ha scritto:the Baltic factory continue to produce fake [notok
Sergio,

I don't think that this one would be a product of the "Baltic Mint". It seems to be the work of a "passionate enthisiast", supposedly from Ukraine.

Marc

Re: Order of the Red Banner of Labor of the Ukraine

Inviato: sab apr 19, 2014 10:22 pm
da SergioV
Lapa ha scritto:
SergioV ha scritto:the Baltic factory continue to produce fake [notok
Sergio,
I don't think that this one would be a product of the "Baltic Mint". It seems to be the work of a "passionate enthisiast", supposedly from Ukraine.
Marc
[264 [264

Re: Order of the Red Banner of Labor of the Ukraine

Inviato: dom apr 20, 2014 2:32 am
da Nota_Bene
Lapa ha scritto:This piece has largely been discussed and commented on Russian forums, and although there is no consensus, the majority of knowledgeable people tend to think that it is a fantasy that was made some time ago on the basis of the sketches for the proposed order.
I certainly have no opinion on it, especially when I only have photos to study. I doubt I will ever receive it for authentication :)

Alexei

Re: Order of the Red Banner of Labor of the Ukraine

Inviato: mer gen 27, 2016 11:05 pm
da SergioV
Another beautiful Order of Red Banner of Labor of Ukraine nr 328
14309b.jpg
14309-ab.jpg